Reflections on 9/11
War as Menstruation Envy...........
This is not a declaration of war. War is a male “menstruation envy” ritual slaughter carried on against humanity in the twisted psychic belief that it will make men whole. It doesn’t. War is a negation, a suppression, not an affirmation. It seeks to eliminate what exists not supplant it, learn from it, make it part of the conscious movement toward justice, equality and liberty.
The subconscious is a powerful force. It drives men’s actions even as they attempt to deny it’s existence. Jung showed us how powerful the collective unconscious is, by looking at Culture’s highest artistic achievements and mysticism and relating the symbolism to the underlying nature of the human psyche. It transcends language both written and spoken and is seen most clearly in the images created in stone carvings, sand paintings, and more contemporary visual arts. The psyche is not culture bound, and has at it’s very root the germ plasm that supports consciousness, language and literacy.
What happened on the way to the forum after 9/11 that framed the dialogue of healing that we needed in the language of war? The epic battle of good versus evil, of winning against an amorphous public enemy, of using all the weapons at our disposal to eliminate once and finally the need for weapons. Hasn’t it become exceedingly clear that weapons and the use of force will never end violence? It is violence.
The dialogue that we need today is a tool not a weapon. It is a way of dredging our inner beings in search of the unseen forces that are driving the human animal, and to harness those forces to lift us to higher planes of consciousness. The kind of tool that has raised us over the animal kingdom to recognize the “I” within, and how it relates to “You” and “We”. The dialogue is not simply an Oral dialogue of “he said, she said”. It is a Written dialogue expressed in the future tense. According to Barry Sanders, professor of English and the History of Ideas at Pitzer College, the alphabetic wholeness has the effect of spreading authority throughout a collection of individuals, a democratizing shift capable of transforming an entire society. We come to our collective identity in the written word. The “Emily” principle, the voice of an agoraphobe, spoken with so much power so many years after her passing. It didn’t matter that she never wandered far from home, she traveled the world with her words and changed it in the process.
We’re searching for that transforming principle today, expressed in twelfth letter terms, love, liberation, longing, legitimacy. The darkness that we want to illuminate with words exists in every individual. We can collectively share the power of illumination by affirming our authority to move “Us” past violence. To bring literacy and the “identity” that is really only possible in literacy to all the people through World Institutions.
That is a big undertaking. It is moving forward. It is progressing from the self imposed limits to the world where borders, the separation between “Us” and “Them”, is eliminated. It is a positive affirmation of a struggle to liberate that portion of the world that lives in darkness. It is the road that leads away from Armageddon, where Women walk without fear, and Children discover truth.
Bob